Rules or Relationship – Pastor Brian Cassell
This detailed briefing document reviews the main themes and important ideas from the provided church service transcript.
Briefing Document: “2025-06-14 – Church Service” Analysis
Date of Service: June 14, 2025 Location: SMC (presumably Spring Meadows Church, based on context) Key Theme: The nature of God’s relationship with humanity, emphasizing grace over strict adherence to rules, exemplified by the parable of the Prodigal Son.
I. Celebrations & Community Life
The service begins with warm greetings and acknowledgments of various community activities and celebrations:
- Father’s Day: The service heavily emphasizes Father’s Day, with special messages for fathers and father figures. The Osorio family opens the service by wishing “Happy Father’s Day,” and later reflections connect the role of earthly fathers to that of God as a “Good Good Father.”
- Anniversaries: Mike and Marilyn Lei are celebrated for their “65 years of marriage,” highlighting longevity and commitment within the church community.
- Youth & Young Adult Activities:Young Adult Gym Night: Scheduled for tonight at 8:00 p.m. at Forest Lake Academy, featuring soccer and basketball.
- Young Adult Kayak Day: Next Sunday at Wekiva State Park.
- Youth Aquatica Trip: Next Sunday to a water park for “summer fun especially these days It is hot out here in Orlando.”
- Homeschool Graduation: This coming Wednesday at 6:30 p.m. in the sanctuary.
- I Recite Ministry: Next Friday at 7:30 p.m. in the Boggs Chapel, a ministry where participants “get to recite Bible verses.” The speaker notes “there’s something powerful that happens when we share and we’re encouraged with God’s word.”
- Joy Group Event: For those 55 and older, a special event on June 22 in the fellowship hall.
- Hospitality: A strong emphasis on welcoming and greeting one another, with an encouragement to “look at somebody you might haven’t seen in a while” and “hug each other and this is an opportunity for us to welcome each other into the house of the Lord.”
II. Worship & Spiritual Focus
The service features contemporary worship songs and a strong emphasis on God’s character and presence:
- Call to Worship: Begins with the song “Come Now is the Time to Worship,” inviting congregants to “Come just as you are to worship.”
- Praise and Adoration: Songs like “Our God is Greater, Our God is Stronger” and “Way Maker, Miracle Worker” highlight God’s power, healing, and constant work in believers’ lives, even when unseen. Key lyrics include: “Way maker miracle worker promise keeper light in the darkness My God that is who you are.”
- God’s Omnipresence and Support: Reinforced by lyrics such as “You are here moving in our midst,” “You are here healing every heart,” and “Even when I don’t see it you’re working Even when I don’t feel it you’re working You never stop You never stop working.”
- Identity in Christ: The song “You’re a Good Good Father” leads into affirmations like “I am chosen not forsaken I am who you say I am You are for me not against me I am who you say I am.”
III. Core Theological Message: Rules vs. Relationship
The central sermon, delivered by a pastor, delves into the nature of God’s law and the human relationship with God, challenging a rules-based understanding of faith.
- Father’s Day Analogy: The sermon begins with a personal anecdote about a father’s playful but firm threat, “I brought you in this world I can take you out,” which is then reframed biblically through Colossians 2:13-15, stating God “forgave all of your sins He canceled the record of your charges against us and took it away by nailing it to the cross.” The speaker reinterprets this to mean God “brought us into this world but through the grace and the sacrifice of his son he is going to take us out.” This emphasizes salvation as a “gift” requiring surrender and acceptance.
- The New Covenant and God’s Law: The sermon reiterates that “the new covenant is simply the reiteration of the one and only main covenant instilled by Jesus after the fall in the Garden of Eden The covenant of salvation through Jesus.” It clarifies that God’s law is “exemplified through God’s law in our lives that it is he who transforms us by his grace.”
- “Rules or Relationship” – The Core Question: The sermon title directly poses the central tension. It uses analogies like differing state laws and the game of Uno to illustrate how people approach rules.
- Uno Analogy: Younger players rigidly follow rules, while older players invent their own “Uno Loco” rules, leading to “humiliation and hopelessness.” This parallels Jean Piaget’s observations of children playing marbles, moving from strict adherence to self-made rules.
- Application to God’s Law: The speaker states that people’s understanding of God’s character and law “may determine how we feel and view this” and “our relationship to him.”
- Colossians 2:13-17 Reinterpretation:
- The common misinterpretation that Colossians 2:13-15 and 16-17 signify the abolition of the Ten Commandments is addressed.
- The speaker firmly states that “what was nailed to the cross what was done away with was what Jesus fulfilled which is no longer needed at the cross After the cross he fulfilled all the symbols that pointed to him.” This refers to “symbolic ceremonies and symbols, the festivals and feasts that pointed to him,” including “special Sabbaths, special new moons, and special food and drink.”
- The Ten Commandments are not done away with, as they are a “relational document” and a “picture of God’s perfect character of love.”
- The Parable of the Prodigal Son (Luke 15): This parable is the central illustrative tool for the “rules or relationship” theme.
- The Younger Brother (Rebel Phase): Seeks independence and wastes his inheritance through “prodigal living.” His understanding of sin is “the absence of right behavior.” He believes he is “far beyond help.”
- The Older Brother (Rules Phase): Remains at home, diligently serving the father, believing his obedience will earn favor. His understanding of sin is “strictly about obedience in the absence of wrong behavior.” He is bitter and resentful when his “misbehaving” brother is celebrated. The speaker notes, “A solemn submission to the will of the father will develop a character of a rebel,” suggesting that a slave mentality, even in obedience, can be a form of rebellion.
- The Father’s Response: Crucially, the father “doesn’t even respond” to the younger son’s rehearsed plea for servitude. Instead, he “ran and fell on his neck and he kissed him,” immediately reinstating him with the “best robe,” a ring, and sandals, and throwing a party.
- The Father’s Character (Relationship Focus): The father “does not come out… to reestablish the broken rules.” Instead, “His heart races to the boys to reestablish the broken relationship.” The father is “not really nearly as concerned in this parable with right and wrong behavior as with the relationship.”
- Both Sons Are Wrong: Both sons operate from a behavior-oriented view of their relationship with the father. The older son by doing everything “right,” the younger by doing everything “wrong.” The sermon states, “They are both absolutely unequivocally wrong,” as “both sons wanted the father’s wealth… but they didn’t want the father.” They were “using the father for their own self-centered ends and not really loving him.”
- Alienation through Obedience or Rebellion: A profound point is made: “We can be alienated from him either by breaking his rules or by keeping all of them diligently.” The older brother was “even more alienated and distant from his father than the younger.”
- God’s Transforming Love: The father knows “what changes a child is not a lecture on behavior What changes a child is the love of a relationship.” This love, displayed on the cross, is an “outstretched hands of Jesus reveal the love of the father The wideopen embrace of the father and son to every runaway rebel every rule-driven elder brother He says ‘Come home to the truth about me.'”
- Call to Action: The sermon concludes with an altar call, inviting both “runaway son[s]” (rebels) and “older brother[s]” (rules-driven but alienated) to “come home” to a relationship with God. It emphasizes that salvation is “by your grace through faith,” a “free gift” that then transforms lives “to be like Jesus.”
IV. Baptism Ceremony
A significant portion of the service is dedicated to the baptism of Olivia, a 9-year-old.
- Family Involvement: Olivia’s parents, Vaughn and Beth Grant (both ordained Adventist pastors), share the privilege of baptizing their daughter. Other family members, including pastors and grandparents, are present.
- Olivia’s Desire: She has wanted to be baptized since age six and has been doing Bible studies with Pastor Alex for a year.
- Tradition & Symbolism: Beth Grant shares her own baptism story, being baptized by her father at age nine. A unique element is the pouring of “actual Jordan River water” into the baptistry, allowing Olivia to be baptized with “the same water that Jesus got baptized in.”
- Olivia’s Letter to Jesus: Olivia wrote a heartfelt letter expressing her love, excitement for baptism, gratitude for her family and Jesus’ sacrifice, and feeling blessed to have Jesus as her “best friend.”
- Public Acknowledgment: The baptism is described as Olivia “acknowledging that and showing us all publicly that you are our Lord and her Savior.”
- Rejoicing in Heaven: The prayer over Olivia states, “the angels are rejoicing with Olivia right now as well.”
- Invitation to Baptism: An open invitation is extended to anyone feeling “the Holy Spirit tug on your heart” to consider baptism, regardless of age or church background.
V. Offering and Father’s Role
The offering segment reinforces the sermon’s themes and the role of fathers.
- Women’s Ministries Offering: Despite it being Father’s Day, the offering is for Women’s Ministries, a point acknowledged with humor. The speaker notes the previous Women’s Ministries offering was for “Adventist disaster response and famine relief,” described as “the most motherly thing.”
- Father’s Responsibility: This leads to a key point about the father’s role: “It isn’t about us It isn’t about us being honored It is about honoring those who helped make us fathers It’s about honoring our children And most of all it’s about being the priest of the home.”
- Spiritual Leadership: The offering for Women’s Ministries is deemed “quite fitting because it is the number one job of a father to be the priest of his home and make sure that the spiritual life of his wife and his children are first and forefront.”
- Outward Role: The prayer emphasizes that the father’s job and the church’s role are “an outward role Lord we have a responsibility,” to “facilitate your soon coming and to help facilitate the gospel being spread to all nations.”
VI. Conclusion
The service concludes with a reaffirmation of God as a “Good Good Father,” a final prayer, and a blessing, emphasizing God’s unchanging law as a picture of His love and the call for the Holy Spirit to transform hearts. Special prayer is offered for those in need at the front of the sanctuary.
Other Sermons In This Series

Rooted in the Word – Pastor Alex Harter
January 04, 2025

Beginnings Matter – Pastor Jonathan Osorio
January 18, 2025